The median home price in New Milford, NJ is $599,000. Currently, there are 37 homes listed in New Milford which include 0 condos, 1 foreclosures. Get started by checking out the most popular home & the most saved home by Better Homes and Gardens® Real Estate homebuyers in the last 30 days. When you are ready to explore homes, read what Better Homes and Gardens® Real Estate agents have to say about New Milford and discover homes for sale in New Milford.